I
have to admit that I hard a difficult time getting through this book during a
difficult time in my life. I thought it would be a fun and easy read,
instead I found myself all kinds of irritated with Arianna, her parents, and
Rachael throughout. Quite a lot of Arianna's struggles mirror my own in
some way and it proved to be triggering. I look forward to
re-reading the book when I'm in a better head space.
Without
further ado: The three questions I'm answering.
1. After Arianna is initially rejected by
Francesca, she wrestles with the idea of telling her co-worker and friend,
Rachel, about it. But then she confesses to herself that by revealing the
criticism she may also be revealing a weakness about herself.
"But if I tell Rachel about that conversation, then I'll
also have to admit that I don't have a clue, and that maybe, just maybe, I
believe that there's some truth in Francesca's fears."
The first thought that came to my mind was: IMPOSTER SYNDROME.
Is this unique to women? Have any others in this book group felt this way?
·
Here’s my personal take on
this question. I definitely have the imposter syndrome due mostly to being
raised by a narcissist. Everything I have accomplished to the present feels
like random luck that no one has figured out that I’m not that great. I still
get this feeling even though in the depths of a really shitty year, I got the
best performance review of my career. It’s a weird place to live, and I can completely
identify with Arianna and the downward spiral that accompanies any rejection
(real or perceived). I don’t know that
this is unique to women, but maybe women are more affected depending on how
they are raised. When you are raised in
a family that demands nothing less than perfection, it’s too easy to view any
type of rejection as a personal attack. When you view rejection as a personal
attack, then every single criticism feels like a revelation of your failings as
a human being. Instead of taking constructive criticism (although Francesca’s
criticism wasn’t exactly constructive) as an opportunity to improve whatever it
is you’re working on, you immediately feel like a complete failure and you don’t
want to reveal that feeling to anyone.
2. Arianna has several major
events that are downplayed by Rachael. How would you have reacted if this had
happened to you? Would you have made the effort to repair the friendship?
·
I
had some trouble figuring out where the relationship between Rachael and
Arianna was going even though I have read the other two books. I guess in knowing that Rachael was planning
another wedding and wrapped up in the wedding, I’d give her a pass. It seemed
to me that Arianna didn’t know how to separate her romantic relationship with Rachael's brother from her relationship with Rachael, so she chose to ignore it while going through all these major life changes.
Many times throughout the book, it seemed that because boundaries had not been
set regarding Arianna’s relationship with Ethan, it was constantly the elephant
in the room when the two friends got together.
I’d say Arianna was more at fault for how their relationship started
falling apart. I was frustrated at both friends for dancing around the issue
and making everything worse.
3. A constant theme in Apart
at the Seams is whether Arianna's relationship with Noah is appropriate.
Arianna wants to believe their friendship is acceptable because she desperately
needs someone who understands the pressures of producing creatively. Rachel
seems to believe her relationship with Noah is unaccceptable, possibly even
bordering on a possible emotional affair. How do you judge Arianna's friendship
with Noah? Would you be comfortable engaging in a similar friendship yourself?
Would you be comfortable with your partner doing so?
To continue the next leg of the book tour, click on over to Lavender Luz
Interesting how your latest performance review was stellar, even as you've been going through a difficult time (and I hope the hard times wrap up very soon).
ReplyDeleteYour answer to #2 makes me think of therapists. I always end up with a therapist I really really like (duh) and want to be friends with. But they aren't allowed to have a dual relationship with me. I think Arianna & Rachel kind of demonstrate how difficult it can be to be two different things to another person.
Thanks for participating!
That happened with my last therapist! And she was the most effective. When she told me that she wasn't allowed to ever contact me after discharge I totally cried.
DeleteThat is so funny that both of you have had this experience too. I just made an appointment with my therapist (who I've been seeing for five years) and she texted back "Excellent!!!" and I thought, that is probably not how therapists are supposed to text back once an appointment is made. I wonder if maybe we are too chummy at this point, but I don't have a lot of friends in my life right now, so I'm not giving her up any time soon.
DeleteI feel that men and women can have a regular friendship and I myself had one once with a co-worker. However, I feel Arianna's and Noahs relationship went beyond a "friendship". It was obvious they were attracted to each other and that they both wanted more than a friendship. It was in a way "emotionally cheating" as Rachel said in the stroy. I wouldn't like my husband to have such a close relationship with another woman and I had a similar relationship with another man, I would most definitely feel like I am betraying my husband/significant other.
ReplyDelete"I had some trouble figuring out where the relationship between Rachael and Arianna was going even though I have read the other two books."
ReplyDeleteI felt the same way. It always felt like kind of an afterthought in Arianna's life and I was never quite sure what was happening between them. It had also been so long since I read the other two books that I couldn't rely on that information either, so I had a hard time with that aspect of the book.
I do know that I would have been pissed if I were Arianna and I thought she gave Rachel way too many free passes. I'm sorry, but a second wedding to the same guy just doesn't seem like reason enough to go AWOL as a friend. I mean, you already had this wedding! To this person! Anyway, that is just me and maybe that is why I don't have many friends.
Notice I said "I guess" on giving a pass to Rachael. I'm with you on the second wedding to the same guy. It doesn't seem like such a big deal. I more came at it an issue with boundaries that Arianna never seemed to set
DeleteI have had a friend in my life who downplayed events in my life and unfortunately it caused the end of our friendship. For Rachel and Arianna there was an added element which was Ethan was Rachel's brother. There were things that Arianna and Ethan kept from Rachel for that very reason. When Arianna discussed Noah with Rachel I think she expected Rachel to put friendship above her brother. I have learned this rarely happens
ReplyDeleteGreat post.
Almost all my best friends are of the opposite sex, so I guess I have a different view on that one :) . The only thing that was weird about it for me was the fact that Arianna herself thought it was weird - which I put down to her perhaps having a more female-centred friendship history.
ReplyDeleteI do remember getting confused and flustered a couple of times as a teenager and then realising that this guy was actually just a really good person to have around, but nobody I'd want to marry and (slash or - in deference to Arianna's thoughts on marriage) raise kids with. One of my best friends got drunk enough once to admit he went through the same process (and out the other side) :) It's pretty natural to me now.
In the book I thought Arianna allowed herself to get a bit too worked up over it and should have just chilled a bit and kept the friend and contact.
I'm sorry the book was read at a hard time. I hope the next read is better. Thank you for participating in this.
ReplyDeleteI definitely think both sexes experience imposter syndrome, but I think men talk themselves out of it whereas women do not. We allow it to influence our decisions whereas men will feel it and then compartmentalize it so they can push ahead. At least, that is what I've observed over the last 40 years.
"...that no one has figured out that I’m not that great." I can really identify with this statement. I'm sorry you've had a hard time.
ReplyDeleteI'm not commenting on the book as I have not read a book (fiction) in over a year. :-) I am just checking in to see how things are going and to see how you are. I'm hoping you are busy with a newborn and unable to post. Thinking of you!
ReplyDeleteAlong with TeeJay...here just checking in on you! Hope the silence means that things are going well!
ReplyDeleteI too think it was an emotional affaire, and I would be upset if it happened to my husband.
ReplyDelete